Grading of SIMS..

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #183882
    NYCaccountant
    Participant

    Are the SIMS graded based on how everyone else performed on the same SIM? If so, how does that work?

    AUD - 99
    BEC - 84
    FAR - 93
    REG - 87
    NYC born and raised.

    FAR - 93
    REG - 87
    BEC - 84!!!!
    AUD - 99!!!!!! CPA exam complete.

Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #560430
    mla1169
    Participant

    No. Before you take your exam it has already been determined how many points each SIM is worth, if any.

    FAR- 77
    AUD -49, 71, 84
    REG -56,75!
    BEC -75

    Massachusetts CPA (non reporting) since 3/12.

    #560431
    F15hy
    Member

    Does anyone know if you receive partial credit for research questions? I know Becker grades it all or nothing, wondering if the exam is the same.

    CA Candidate

    B-79 (4th Attempt, finally killed you Nov 2013)
    A-81 (3rd Attempt, Feb 2014) AND I AM DONE!!!!!
    R-80 (1st Attempt, Feb 2013)
    F-77 (2nd attempt, Jan 2014)

    Becker, Becker Final Review, NINJA 10-Point Combo
    ($M.O.B$)

    CA Ethics-92%

    #560432
    party dude
    Participant

    i wrote to the AICPA asking this question and here is the reply i got:

    “For the AUD, FAR, or REG section, answers to the questions across the 6 or 7 TBSs are used as a single collection of responses to determine the single score for the TBS portion of the section. The individual tasks are not weighted. Note: the response to the Research TBS is a single citation from the Authoritative Literature. Accordingly, each Research TBS is treated and scored as a single response. For both the MCQ and TBS portions of the exam, credit is given only for correct responses. There is no penalty for incorrect responses.

    For BEC, each of the written communication tasks is scored individually and the single written communication score is then obtained as the average of the individual essay scores.”

    #560433
    F15hy
    Member

    Interesting, thanks jdm 🙂

    CA Candidate

    B-79 (4th Attempt, finally killed you Nov 2013)
    A-81 (3rd Attempt, Feb 2014) AND I AM DONE!!!!!
    R-80 (1st Attempt, Feb 2013)
    F-77 (2nd attempt, Jan 2014)

    Becker, Becker Final Review, NINJA 10-Point Combo
    ($M.O.B$)

    CA Ethics-92%

    #560434
    party dude
    Participant

    any time, F15hy!

    #560435
    Not a Quitter
    Participant

    Whoa, I'm not even sure what AICPA's response means. My brain is fried. Are they essentially saying the SIMS are “curved”?

    FAR- 85 I'm DONE!
    BEC- 75
    REG- 60,60,75
    AUD- 74,74,83

    CPAExcel used for BEC, AUD, REG
    Exam Matrix used for FAR plus NINJA Blitz, cpareviewforfree and a little CPAExcel

    #560436

    Basically it reads like this:

    “We really have no idea how we grade these things and it all depends on our mood that day. We add comic relief to our day by reading posts on Another71 of candidates who grow continually frustrated by taking and re-taking tests. We send out score reports that let candidates know that even though they scored “stronger” than passing candidates we will still give them a 74 because they couldn't figure out how to pass SIMS using the only proven study formula: reading our minds. Please continue to try to figure out our methods as they keep us entertained and help contribute to the building improvements and new billiards table in the staff lounge.”

    "If you're going through hell, keep going"
    - Winston Churchill

    "I've missed over 9,000 shots in my career. I've lost over 300 games. 26 times I've been trusted to take the game winning shot, and missed. I've failed, over and over and over again in my life. And that is why, I succeed."
    - Michael Jordan

    BEC: (54), (72), 80 (losing credit on 02/02/15 - nervous)
    AUD: 78
    REG: (74), 91
    FAR: (71)

    #560437
    F15hy
    Member

    Hahahah, Ron B, you're hilarious! That definitely deserves a HiYa

    CA Candidate

    B-79 (4th Attempt, finally killed you Nov 2013)
    A-81 (3rd Attempt, Feb 2014) AND I AM DONE!!!!!
    R-80 (1st Attempt, Feb 2013)
    F-77 (2nd attempt, Jan 2014)

    Becker, Becker Final Review, NINJA 10-Point Combo
    ($M.O.B$)

    CA Ethics-92%

    #560438
    noleguy
    Member

    Awesome Ron B. Touche!!!!! Lol!!

    #560439
    Not a Quitter
    Participant

    Ron, I truly believe the above mentioned association is sadistic!!! They give us just enough information to make us crazy trying to figure everything out. It's sick!!!

    FAR- 85 I'm DONE!
    BEC- 75
    REG- 60,60,75
    AUD- 74,74,83

    CPAExcel used for BEC, AUD, REG
    Exam Matrix used for FAR plus NINJA Blitz, cpareviewforfree and a little CPAExcel

    #560440
    Study Monk
    Member

    I think the AICPA means that every question in every TBS(Task Based Simulation) is worth the same as reflected by “not weighted”. Not every TBS is worth the same, but every little task within each TBS is worth the same.

    questions across the 6 or 7 TBSs are used as a single collection of responses to determine the single score for the TBS portion of the section”

    I think this above quote agrees with what I stated above; that every Sim has sub questions and every sub question is worth the same. A sub question needs to be 100% correct to get credit, and all of the answers you get right are added up in a similar fashion as the multiple choice to determine your overall score.

    All research questions need to be 100% correct to get credit as reflected by “TBS is a single citation from the Authoritative Literature. Accordingly, each Research TBS is treated and scored as a single response.” Research questions are worth the same as every other SINGLE fill in the box type question you have on the other TBS's. To clarify 1 research question is NOT worth 1/7 of the Sims, but could be worth 1/35 of the Sims if there are a lot of individual tasks within the Sims.

    The above citation does not appear to imply a curve. I feel like John Nash right now, hopefully I don't go crazy and start writing on the walls.

    I spoke to an ancient wise man who sent me on a mushroom induced journey through an ancient forest to find the key to passing the CPA exam. A talking spider monkey told me to throw the last of my drinking water in the dirt to find what I was looking for. So I followed his instructions and the following message appeared in the soil:

    "Do 5000 multiple choice questions for each section"

    #560441
    F15hy
    Member

    Someone's got their thinking cap on this morning haha, that makes sense Monk.

    CA Candidate

    B-79 (4th Attempt, finally killed you Nov 2013)
    A-81 (3rd Attempt, Feb 2014) AND I AM DONE!!!!!
    R-80 (1st Attempt, Feb 2013)
    F-77 (2nd attempt, Jan 2014)

    Becker, Becker Final Review, NINJA 10-Point Combo
    ($M.O.B$)

    CA Ethics-92%

    #560442
    Guti
    Participant

    What will happen if in a sub question within a simulation, you get the JE account correct, but the number next to the account is incorrect, do you get half of a total point, or the whole answer in wrong even though you chose the correct account?

    FAR-84
    AUD-
    REG-
    BEC-

    #560443
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    ^^

    thats a good question. also, if a box is supposed to be blank and you put zeros do you get partial credit for that

    #560444
    CPA soon
    Member

    I think it's graded based on each individual cell, so whether an account name or amount any cell you have correct adds points. That's only a guess but I don't think I would have gotten comparable if that wasn't the case lol. And noone would have probably passed in a million years lol

    FAR - 71, 68, 74, (8/31/14) 78 ✔
    REG - 67, 71, 71, (10/18/14) 78 ✔
    BEC - (11/29/14) 86 ✔
    AUD - 73, (4/4/15) 86 ✔

    I can't believe this is over! 2 years and 3 months..

Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.