@baseball cpa....I'll answer your question.
As the parent of a child with ADD and probably an undiagnosed sufferer myself, I can answer your question and misconceptions.
My Son's case was one where he began having trouble in the second grade when classes began introducing more difficult schoolwork. His symptoms were that he was quickly overwhelmed when trying to learn easy math for instance--kind of the way we feel after a long weekend of CPA studying, where we cannot pack anything else in and information stops making sense. I fought the medications for him thinking that it was just doctors creating billings for themselves and the drug industry. Finally our Pediatrician asked us to just try the medication once for a couple days and see what happened. That corresponded with some standardized testing my son was being allowed to retake because in second grade he tested at a beginner first grade level. We started him on it on a Monday, he retook the test on that Thursday and scored at a fourth grade level. Since then it's been gangbusters. ADD medication isn't a magic pill, it simply removes barriers that are preventing your pure potential from being realized. If ADD medication was a 'smart pill' that made people smarter or more capable than they really are in life, everyone would be on it and it would be the new normal. What was that movie...oh yeah Limitless would be a reality.
As for myself, I have gone untreated although I know I have it. Counter to the misconception that ADD/ADHD people can't focus, that's actually a fallacy. Hyperfocus is one of the hallmarks of ADD/ADHD. For instance, since starting the CPA study, it is all I can do to manage my work duties. Things I routinely handled with great precision and absolutely mastery are now giving me fits and trying to manage projects that I was in absolute control of a few weeks ago is a chore. It's like whatever is at the forefront of my mind at any given time pushes out everything else. If I sit down and try to study, relax, or pray...I have 10,000 things going through my head. The best analogy is like there are 40 people in the room with you who are whispering in your ear, one after another, about any given topic. At times, it is just a handful quitely whispering and diverting your attention....other times it is like they are all talking at the same time in a frenzy.
If you have seen the kid's movie UP, there is a talking Dog in the movie who is always excited to tell the other characters something. Then in mid-sentence he yells "SQUIRREL" and forgets what he was saying to run off and chase the squirrel. We laugh about that with myself or my son when we're mid-sentence and one of the distractions runs us off on some rabbit trail. My wife will say "SQUIRREL" and we'll go back to what we were saying.
It makes studying an extreme challenge. Despite it, I have my EA and graduated with honors from my MBA program and (with the grace of God and a little hope&luck) just passed the auditing portion of the CPA exam on Wednedsay of this week.
I think that if people can find coping mechanisms, that's the best solution and what has helped me. But for some medication is the workaround (notice I didn't say solution). The meds don't cure it, they just take away most of the disadvantages of the ADD. From my experience with my son the meds don't put the person on an even playing field with the others (timed tests are usually a problem and the medicated ADD sufferer still has to work extra hard to keep up and amazingly hard to excel). Also, the meds introduce other problems such as tics which can be just as distracting as the ADD.
So as someone with experience, I don't see that giving bonafide ADD people (medicated or not) a little extra time is an unfair accommodation or gives them a leg up.
CPAPending
AUD 87 Jan 2012
BEC 88 Feb 2012
REG 5/29/2012
FAR 8/31/2012
A CPA Flatliner for years now...looking forward to being revived in September 2012.